How to Choose the Best Dating Photos: Science-Backed Tips
When it comes to online dating apps, choosing the best dating photos is crucial because your photos do most of the talking. In fact, they’re your first impression, conversation starter, and virtual handshake rolled into one. So, how do you make your photos stand out? Christian Rudder’s book Dataclysm reveals intriguing insights into human behavior, including the secrets behind choosing the best dating photos that thrive on dating platforms. If you’re curious to explore more about his findings, you can check out the book here. Here, we dive into the data-driven strategies to choose the best photos for online dating apps and land more matches.
The Power of Facial Expressions in Choosing the Best Dating Photos
Women: Smile Like You Mean It
Studies show that smiling in photos makes women appear approachable, friendly, and more attractive to men. So, whether it’s a big grin or a subtle smile, show those pearly whites.
Men: Confidence Over Smiles
A slightly serious or neutral expression often works better for men. It conveys confidence and a hint of mystery, which many women find irresistible.
The Magic of Eye Contact
Direct eye contact in photos creates a sense of connection and intimacy, making it an instant win for both men and women. It’s like saying, “Yes, I see you—and you should swipe right.”
Angles and Composition: Essential for the Best Dating Photos
Real-Life Example: The Power of the Right Angle
Let’s compare two photos of Kerry. In the first photo, Kerry’s selfie is taken in poor lighting and from a close-up, low angle, creating an unflattering perspective (not ideal). In the second photo, Kerry is photographed in a relaxed, well-lit environment with an engaging pose, showing him playing the guitar. The difference is striking: the second photo highlights personality, confidence, and better composition—making it far more appealing.
The lesson? Angles can make or break your dating photos. A simple adjustment can take your photo from “meh” to “match.”
Close-Ups vs. Full Body Shots
For women, close-up photos that emphasize the face often perform better. Men, on the other hand, tend to get more traction with full-body shots, especially those showcasing fitness or engaging activities.
Symmetry: Nature’s Beauty Code
Facial symmetry has long been associated with attractiveness. While you can’t change your genetics, choosing well-angled photos that flatter your features can make a world of difference.
Activities and Context: Bring Out the Best Dating Photos
Action Shots That Spark Curiosity
Photos that show you engaged in an activity—whether hiking, biking, or traveling—do more than look good. They serve as conversation starters and highlight your adventurous side.
Aesthetic Environments Matter
Swap the messy bedroom selfie for photos taken outdoors or in visually appealing settings. A clean, well-lit background can elevate your photo’s appeal instantly.
Need a way to keep the conversation flowing? Use my Dating Conversation Icebreakers to turn those hobbies and activities into engaging stories.
Lighting and Authenticity: How to Choose the Best Dating Photos
Quirky Tip: Say Goodbye to Bathroom Selfies
If your current dating profile includes a bathroom selfie with a toilet in the background, we need to talk. Poor lighting and distracting backgrounds scream “last-minute effort.” Instead, step outside, find a spot with soft natural light, and let your personality shine. Your future matches (and their eyeballs) will thank you.
Use Natural Light to Your Advantage
Photos taken in natural light tend to outperform those with artificial or harsh lighting. Position yourself near a window or step outside for the perfect glow.
Authenticity Over Filters
Skip the heavy filters. Candid, unedited photos are seen as more genuine and trustworthy. People want to connect with the real you, not an airbrushed version.
Nervous about your next date? Pair your stunning photos with confidence-boosting tools like my Free Guided Affirmations to calm those first-date nerves.
Why Science Backs the Best Dating Photos
The Halo Effect
Attractive photos don’t just draw more attention—they also create an unconscious bias where viewers perceive you as more likable and competent. Make those first impressions count.
Emotional Contagion
Smiles and positive expressions evoke warm, fuzzy feelings in the viewer. It’s a win-win: you appear friendly, and they feel good just looking at your photo.
When Strong Dating Photos Still Don’t Convert
Science-backed photo advice can absolutely help — but strong individual photos don’t always guarantee a strong profile.
In many cases, the issue is more subtle: photo order, mixed visual signals, or images that don’t fully support the story your profile is telling as a whole.
That’s exactly why I offer the Match-Ready™ Profile Audit — a professional review of your dating profile that looks at how your photos and prompts work together, not just whether each image is “good.”
It’s designed for people who want clarity before investing in new photos.
👉
Learn more about the Match-Ready™ Profile Audit
(This is not a photo critique — it’s perspective on how your profile is actually read.)
Practical Steps to Choose the Best Dating Photos
- Use natural light and simple, distraction-free backgrounds.
- Select photos that highlight your personality through activities or settings.
- For women: Smile! For men: Opt for confident, neutral expressions.
- Avoid over-editing or excessive filters—keep it authentic.
- Ensure all photos are high resolution and well-composed.
Want a quick and actionable guide to perfect your dating profile photos? Download my Dating Profile Photo CheatSheet for step-by-step tips and expert insights. It’s your ultimate resource to ensure your photos stand out and attract the right matches.
Your photos are just the start. After your date, reflect on what worked and what didn’t with my Free Post-Date Reflection Journal to fine-tune your profile and approach.
Conclusion: The Science of Swiping Success
When it comes to online dating apps, choosing the best photos is both an art and a science. By understanding what attracts the opposite sex and leveraging proven techniques, you can turn those swipes into real connections. So grab your camera (or hire a pro!), pick the right light, and show off the best version of yourself. The perfect match might just be one great photo away.
Want to keep learning how to master your online dating profile? Subscribe to The Heart of Attraction Newsletter for exclusive tips, tricks, and insights to make your dating journey smoother and more successful.
If you’re ready to step up your dating profile game, consider professional photos. I offer Professional Dating Profile Photography to help you capture your best angles and attract the matches you deserve.
Hi — I’m Shannon O’Malley.
I’m a Minneapolis-based (soon-to-be Dallas, TX) photographer specializing in online dating profile photography, personal branding portraits, business headshots, and senior sessions. I work with people who want photos that feel natural, confident, and genuinely reflective of who they are — not stiff, overproduced, or performative.
My approach is rooted in natural light, ease, and emotional intelligence. I believe the best photos happen when people feel comfortable enough to be themselves — and seen enough to trust the process. Whether someone is stepping back into dating, refining their professional presence, or marking a meaningful season of life, my goal is always the same: to create images that feel honest and quietly powerful.
With over 15 years of experience behind the camera — and a journey that includes single motherhood, entrepreneurship, and a national CBS feature — I’ve seen firsthand how much impact the right photos can have. A strong image isn’t about vanity. It’s about clarity. It’s often the first impression that shapes how others perceive you — before you ever get the chance to explain yourself.
This blog is where I share insights on photography, visibility, confidence, and showing up with intention — both on and off camera.
When I’m not photographing clients, you’ll usually find me with my husband, my son, and our beautifully blended family — soaking up everyday life here in the Twin Cities (for now). We’ll be relocating to Dallas, Texas in 2026, where I’ll continue offering my signature photography experience for daters, creatives, and business owners throughout the DFW area.
If you’re here because you want photos that actually feel like you, you’re in the right place. I’m glad you found your way here.
Leave a Reply
As Seen In & Featured On:
Love that you are bringing actual science into dating photo advice. So much of the advice out there is just opinions but having research backed tips is way more helpful. I have been using SceneYou to get different photo options and it has been interesting to see which ones actually get more matches. The data driven approach you mention makes so much sense – why guess when you can use actual evidence right?
Love that you are bringing actual science into dating photo advice. So much of the advice out there is just opinions but having research backed tips is way more helpful. I have been using SceneYou.art to get different photo options and it is been interesting to see which ones actually get more matches. The data driven approach you mention makes so much sense – why guess when you can use actual evidence right?
Thank you so much for this — I really appreciate you taking the time to share it.
You’re exactly right: so much dating photo advice is based on opinion or trends, not evidence. That’s why I’m so passionate about grounding this work in how profiles are actually processed — visually, emotionally, and cognitively — not just what people think should work.
I love that you mentioned experimenting and observing real results, too. That curiosity — noticing patterns instead of guessing — is where clarity starts. Dating profiles don’t fail because people “aren’t attractive enough”; they fail because the signal gets muddled.
I’m curious — when you started paying closer attention to which photos performed better, what surprised you most?
Really glad this post resonated with you. Thanks again for being here and adding to the conversation.